You Are Here:

Community: Blogs

Nathan Eagle's Forum Nokia Blog

Who Owns YOUR Location?

natecow | 09 November, 2006 13:25

I recently finished serving as an expert witness in a court case in which I had to provide my opinion about the possible locations of a mobile phone given cellular tower IDs and base station positions. While this information had to be subpoenaed from Verizon as part of the litigation, it may be disconcerting for some to acknowledge that in databases distributed throughout the world, mobile phone service providers are storing records of location and social network data for one out of three people on Earth.


Besides the data’s obvious utility in courtroom trial cases like the one I was testifying in, I’m curious about the long-term consequences of commercial companies recording a time series of locations and communication events for billions of people. Who legally owns this data? Because carriers like T-Mobile & Sprint now publicly disclose the locations of their towers, base station locations are no longer the corporate secret they once were, and subsequently can’t be used to prevent customers from obtaining the location information collected about them. If I ask my T-Mobile representative to provide me with my call log history, they don’t seem to have a problem with disclosing my communication events to me. However, when asked to provide me with an approximation of the locations associated with each of my calls, they still claim this is prohibited. So, empirically at least, it doesn’t appear that the customers own the location data collected about them. And if the customers don’t own this information, then I imagine by default, the mobile operators are the ones who own the records of movement data for all of their customers.


What guidelines do mobile operators have to abide by when using this data? Can it be sold to a 3rd party? How much would a detailed time-series of my locations over the last five years go for on Ebay? Who would be the highest bidder? Urban planning consultants interested in public transportation usage? Companies working on developing the next census? Wall St traders interested in where I’m doing my grocery shopping?


This data clearly has value. Already carriers are selling real-time location information to companies who use this information to extrapolate the location and speed of the individual and use this data to offer road traffic updates and forecasts. As the major carriers’ billion dollar networks turn into a commodity infrastructure, mobile operators are going to be ever more interested in monetizing the location data generated from their customers. (“This speeding ticket has been brought to you courtesy of <insert your mobile service provider of choice>.”)


So here is an exercise for the interested reader – call up your own service provider and ask for the location information associated with your call logs. Let me know if you’ve had any luck.

RSSComments

Re: Who Owns YOUR Location?

coultonp | 09/11/2006, 15:31

coultonp Nathan

You raise a very interesting point and in the UK we also have free access to mobile cell sites through the handy OFCOM site (www.sitefinder.radio.gov.uk) which allows you to search via post code, street, name etc. Each site has all the information you would expect height, power, frequency, type of transmission (UMTS, GSM) and operator ref. One might expect that it would then be easy to correlate these operator refs to cell ids and thus obtain location but having experimented with this it seems that these refs are independent of cell id. This would seem somewhat illogical unless the cell-id location is commoditised which indeed is the case here for any one trying to create location based services based on cell-id positioning.

As we are expecting to see the launch of an MVNO offering free advertisement supported voice, text and content in Europe next summer a logical extension of there operation would be to utilise location as a commodity to the advertisers.

I havent tried getting my location info from the operator but I suspect I will get a similar response to the one you received but I will let you know. (Not sure how data protection act would view this in terms of accessing your own)

Re: Who Owns YOUR Location?

hartti | 09/11/2006, 19:02

hartti In U.S. you can do a similar cell tower search for example through http://www.cellreception.com/

Hartti

Re: Who Owns YOUR Location?

jspar | 18/01/2007, 08:26

47 USC 222 answers most of your questions.

Location information cannot be used unless the user provides express authorization. (opt-in)
You must login to post comments. Login
 

Rate This

 
 
Bookmark this page: DeliciousDiggFacebookGoogleYahooStumbleUponRedditDiigoTechnocratiTwitter  Share this page Share this page Print this Page Print this page Invite a friend Invite a friend
京ICP备05048969号    Email Newsletters Press Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Sitemap Contact Us © 2009 Nokia 
RDF Facets: qdcZdescriptionQSxsharingE20myE20eE78perienceE20withE20othersE21E20WelcomeE20toE20myE20blogE2eE20WelcomeE20toE20myE20websiteE20HttpE3aE2fE2fwwwE2esymbianerE2ecomE20coolE5fliE20E7cE2011E20AprilE2cE202007E2011E3a03E20GoogleE20VoiceE2dActivatedE20E4cocalE20SearchE2cE20thatE27sE20aE20greateE20originalityE2eInE20anE20effortE20toE20provideE20usersE20withE20optionsE20forE20findingE20localE20businessesE20whileE20onE20theE20goE2cE20GoogleE20hasE20introducedE20aE20betaE20searchE20applicationE20calledE20GoogleE20VoiceE20E4cocalE20SearchE2eE20ThisE20eE78perimentalE20411E20serviceE2cE20withE20functionalityE20similarE20toE20GoogleE27sE20eE78istingE20GoogleE20MapsE20applicationE2cE20offersE20anE20alternativeE20toE20usE2eE2eE2eX qdcZidentifierQSxhttpE3aE2fE2fblogsE2eforumE2enokiaE2ecomE2fblogE2fliE2dyongfeisE2dforumE2dnokiaE2dblogE2f2007E2f04E2f11E2fgoogleE2dsE2dvoiceE2dactivatedE2dlocalE2dsearchX qdcZpublisherQUxhttpE3aE2fE2fswE2enokiaE2ecomE2fidE2fc764fd1cE2d8b06E2d499aE2d9a6aE2d17c3903d5a65E2fforumE5fnokiaE5fcrawlerE5fagentX qdcZtitleQSxE4ciE20YongfeiE27sE20ForumE20NokiaE20BlogE20E7cE20GoogleE27sE20VoiceE2dActivatedE20E4cocalE20SearchX qdcZtypeQUqfnZE45E78cludedFromGeneralE4cistingsQ qdcZtypeQUqfntypeZBlogContentQ qdcZtypeQUqfntypeZBlogE45ntryQ qdcZtypeQUqfntypeZCommunityContentQ qdcZtypeQUqfntypeZE52esourceQ qdcZtypeQUqfntypeZWebpageQ qdcZtypeQUqmarsZManagedE52esourceQ qdcZtypeQUqwebZInformationE52esourceQ qdcZtypeQUqwebZPageQ qdcZtypeQUqwebZE52esourceQ qdcZtypeQUqrdfsZE52esourceQ qrssZdescriptionQSxsharingE20myE20eE78perienceE20withE20othersE21E20WelcomeE20toE20myE20blogE2eE20WelcomeE20toE20myE20websiteE20HttpE3aE2fE2fwwwE2esymbianerE2ecomE20coolE5fliE20E7cE2011E20AprilE2cE202007E2011E3a03E20GoogleE20VoiceE2dActivatedE20E4cocalE20SearchE2cE20thatE27sE20aE20greateE20originalityE2eInE20anE20effortE20toE20provideE20usersE20withE20optionsE20forE20findingE20localE20businessesE20whileE20onE20theE20goE2cE20GoogleE20hasE20introducedE20aE20betaE20searchE20applicationE20calledE20GoogleE20VoiceE20E4cocalE20SearchE2eE20ThisE20eE78perimentalE20411E20serviceE2cE20withE20functionalityE20similarE20toE20GoogleE27sE20eE78istingE20GoogleE20MapsE20applicationE2cE20offersE20anE20alternativeE20toE20usE2eE2eE2eX qfnZdistributionQUxhttpE3aE2fE2fblogsE2eforumE2enokiaE2ecomE2fX qfnZtopicQUqfnTopicZbusinessE5fopportunitiesE5fservicesQRqdcZtypeQUqrdfsZE52esourceQRqmarsZrelevanceQNx100X qfnZtopicQUqfnTopicZbusinessE5ftechnicalE5fservicesQRqmarsZrelevanceQNx100X qfnZtopicQUqfnTopicZlocationQRqdcZtypeQUqrdfsZE52esourceQRqmarsZrelevanceQNx100X qfnZtypeQUqfntypeZBlogContentQ qfnZtypeQUqfntypeZBlogE45ntryQ qfnZtypeQUqfntypeZCommunityContentQ qfnZtypeQUqfntypeZE52esourceQ qfnZtypeQUqfntypeZWebpageQ qfnZupdatedQDx2007E2d04E2d11X qfnZuserE5ftagQSxbusinessE2dopportunitiesE2fservicesX qfnZuserE5ftagQSxbusinessE2ftechnicalE2dservicesX qfnZuserE5ftagQSxlocationE2dbasedE2dservicesX qmarsZdescriptionQSxsharingE20myE20eE78perienceE20withE20othersE21E20WelcomeE20toE20myE20blogE2eE20WelcomeE20toE20myE20websiteE20HttpE3aE2fE2fwwwE2esymbianerE2ecomE20coolE5fliE20E7cE2011E20AprilE2cE202007E2011E3a03E20GoogleE20VoiceE2dActivatedE20E4cocalE20SearchE2cE20thatE27sE20aE20greateE20originalityE2eInE20anE20effortE20toE20provideE20usersE20withE20optionsE20forE20findingE20localE20businessesE20whileE20onE20theE20goE2cE20GoogleE20hasE20introducedE20aE20betaE20searchE20applicationE20calledE20GoogleE20VoiceE20E4cocalE20SearchE2eE20ThisE20eE78perimentalE20411E20serviceE2cE20withE20functionalityE20similarE20toE20GoogleE27sE20eE78istingE20GoogleE20MapsE20applicationE2cE20offersE20anE20alternativeE20toE20usE2eE2eE2eX qmarsZlanguageQUxhttpE3aE2fE2fswE2enokiaE2ecomE2flanguageE2d1E2fenX qrdfZtypeQUqfnZE45E78cludedFromGeneralE4cistingsQ qrdfZtypeQUqfntypeZBlogContentQ qrdfZtypeQUqfntypeZBlogE45ntryQ qrdfZtypeQUqfntypeZCommunityContentQ qrdfZtypeQUqfntypeZE52esourceQ qrdfZtypeQUqfntypeZWebpageQ qrdfZtypeQUqmarsZManagedE52esourceQ qrdfZtypeQUqwebZInformationE52esourceQ qrdfZtypeQUqwebZPageQ qrdfZtypeQUqwebZE52esourceQ qrdfZtypeQUqrdfsZE52esourceQ